RS3 or M4?

Wilkeh · Feb 15, 2018

I want CS’s genuine opinion on this, I’m on the lookout for a new car and recently put down a deposit on a RS3 (refundable). However, my budget is around £35,000 so I’ve been looking into other cars for the same price. What’s your thoughts on the M4? It’s the same price and weirdly enough it’s half to price to insure than the RS3. I’m thinking the RS3 is classier, and certainly rarer (I don’t think I’ve actually seen one to be honest), where as the BMW I’ve seen a few times. The BMW however could be a lot of fun, but then would I be “that” BMW wanker guy.

These are the main two examples –

https://www.pistonheads.com/classif...s3-2-5-tfsi-rs-3-quattro-5dr-s-tronic/8091958

https://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/bmw/f82-m4/bmw-m4/8247013

Thoughts?

Budgie · Feb 15, 2018

I really don't get the M4 hate - i think they're the best looking M car for ages.

///M all the way.

Jamess182 · Feb 15, 2018

Agreed, gotta be the M4. Especially in that colour.

Budgie · Feb 15, 2018

Subtle-ish FTW

Knuckles · Feb 15, 2018

Budgie said:
I really don't get the M4 hate - i think they're the best looking M car for ages.

///M all the way.

Wrong amount of doors iirc.

M3 is an undisputed drivers car. M4 is a piece of s**t.

As much as I love an rs3. I’d have to go m4 out of the two. So much more for the money.

If it was rs3 or m2 I’d probably say rs3

cat171 · Feb 15, 2018

I think the M3's look way better than M4's, so I go with the RS3.. although tbh I'd always be on edge about it getting nicked.

rich_h · Feb 15, 2018

M4 for me, the RS3's sound great and put the power down well but you will get bored very quickly...

RDH · Feb 15, 2018

dablk · Feb 15, 2018

+1 for the M3 looking much better than the M4.

Don't know enough about the RS3 hasn't it just been revised? Appreciate out your budget new but would that bother you? Where as the m3/m4 has a legs for a little while longer.

Short Norman · Feb 15, 2018

RDH said:
M3.

I've voted M4 but it rare I see one that I like, much prefer the M3. Get an M3 before they stop making them later this year.

is an F10 M5 not an option?

leedsboy · Feb 15, 2018

I must be the only person that prefers the M4 to the M3, I think they look great, but just not in that horrible Blue colour that's linked.

I do love RS3's as well though.

JB21 · Feb 15, 2018

C63 :tongueout:

dablk · Feb 15, 2018

JB21 said:
C63 :tongueout:

...noise :up:

mantis946 · Feb 15, 2018

The RS3’s are cracking cars are pretty rare as you say, engine note is special and they are unbelievably quick off the line. Suffer from understeer from what I’ve experienced so a rear ARB helps, pretty tuneable platform by all accounts.

Budgie · Feb 15, 2018

dablk said:
...noise :up:

And complete lack of traction in anything other than bone dry conditions, lol

The Chubby Pirate · Feb 15, 2018

Surprised about folk saying the 8v RS3 being rare, i’ve seen about 6/7 in the last month i reckon.

M4’s again, seen quite a few.

Would be the RS3 for me.

Short Norman · Feb 15, 2018

Budgie said:
And complete lack of traction in anything other than bone dry conditions, lol

I don't think the M4 is renowned for brilliant traction either.

JB21 · Feb 15, 2018

I personally think the RS3's are a bit Barry, the BM albeit a great car a bit dull but the c63's noise is just car p**n although also a bit Barry. My head would say m4 but I think I'd always regret not getting the Merc.

Out the OP's choice it would be the M4.

ForceIndia · Feb 15, 2018

Budgie said:
I really don't get the M4 hate - i think they're the best looking M car for ages.

///M all the way.

Have you driven one?

Budgie · Feb 15, 2018

ForceIndia said:
Have you driven one?

I have not. What they like?

Ant1 · Feb 15, 2018

RS3s everywhere filled with talentless traffic light wanna be Grand Prix drivers. If you want envolement get the M4.

Fletcher · Feb 15, 2018

Ex-User (19928) · Feb 15, 2018

RWD over AWD any day of the week.

RS3 is a cool car, but f**k spending that much on a fast car and not being able to do hero skids.

Cookson · Feb 15, 2018

I like the look and noise of the RS3, but f**k getting your front door kicked in and held to knifepoint at 3am for the keys.

M4 or C63

ForceIndia · Feb 15, 2018

Budgie said:
I have not. What they like?

Weird engine. Throttle response is odd, nothing nothing bang. Then all the power seems to arrive in one go, completely overwhelming the chassis.

New ones meant to be much better (revised mapping etc). It's not a patch on the c63 (imo)

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

Ian_182 · Feb 15, 2018

M4 all day for the power, the drive and the interior which is night and day over the A3.

Wilkeh · Feb 15, 2018

Thanks for the input guys, I'm definitely swaying towards the M4. The RS3 in effect is a £30k+ Audi A3. The BMW certainly looks £30k+

massiveCoRbyn · Feb 15, 2018

I'd probably lean towards the BMW, but have never driven either. Do prefer the M3 to the M4 in terms of looks though.

I must say though, I know a couple of guys with RS Audis, an RS3 and a TT RS, and with a few mods, they sound unbelievable. Five pots are so awesome. But the fact a Golf R is actually quicker around a lot of tracks would annoy me 😂

Ian_182 · Feb 15, 2018

Cheapest competition one ive seen.
https://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/bmw/f82-m4/bmw-m4-m4-2dr-dct/8147061

roberto. · Feb 15, 2018

In the linked adverts, the M4. Better colour, better interior, who buys an RS3 and doesn't spec super sport seats?

Short Norman · Feb 15, 2018

Cookson said:
I like the look and noise of the RS3, but f**k getting your front door kicked in and held to knifepoint at 3am for the keys.

M4 or C63

with an M4 they just boost the signal that's emitted from the key (used for comfort access) and drive off in the car without needing to come into your house. Saves the hassle of being woken up I suppose.

SuperJ · Feb 15, 2018

My neighbour opposite has an M4 in a sort of washed out red colour. Could well be the colour that makes it look a bit crap, but an RS3 a few streets over just sounds fantastic and I would choose it for the sound alone over the M4. Probably isnt standard tbf.

Ex-User (19928) · Feb 15, 2018

thekopistop said:
My neighbour opposite has an M4 in a sort of washed out red colour. Could well be the colour that makes it look a bit crap, but an RS3 a few streets over just sounds fantastic and I would choose it for the sound alone over the M4. Probably isnt standard tbf.

With a sports exhaust they're pretty ASBO to be honest.

@Op (@Wilkeh ) Would you actually drive the M4 like a champ (i.e. with traction/stability turned off and hanging the back end out) or is this just a fast car that looks fast? If it's the latter then I'd get the RS3, better in car entertainment.

Matt W · Feb 15, 2018

ian 182 said:
Cheapest competition one ive seen.
https://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/bmw/f82-m4/bmw-m4-m4-2dr-dct/8147061

That sunroof photo, they didn't even bother painting it!

Matt W · Feb 15, 2018

Guy in work has an m3 like this, delicious.

Waitey · Feb 15, 2018

Totally different cars. Depend what you want from one. (Coming from someone who did 40k in a year in a RS3).

cat171 · Feb 15, 2018

M3's with the comp pack wheels etc look the bollox! The one on The Grand Tour last week was lovely.

Crybert · Feb 15, 2018

I voted m4 but also agree the m3 looks better proportioned.

AdDaMan · Feb 15, 2018

M3>M4>RS3

Rojer · Feb 15, 2018

Between the M4 and RS3 i would prefer the RS3. The M4 noise is pretty horrid in my imo. If i had to buy an M4 i would save a bit more and get a CS or potentially just an Alpina.

RS3 or M4?

Which car

Rs3

M4

Brembo! Brembo! Brembo!

Similar threads